Microsoft Corporation (MSFT) Could Lose Android Earnings Soon; More Legal And Business Challeges Ahead!

Must Read

 Microsoft Corporation (NASDAQ:MSFT) has been minting millions of dollars for last few years from Google Inc. (NASDAQ:GOOGL) owned Android. The Windows Phone OS maker owns at least 20 of  Android’s key patents and has now acquired even more patents after the US$7.2 billion acquisition of Nokia. In the recent past, the Redmond Giant had forced several smartphone OEM’s such as HTC Corp (TPE:2498) and ZTE Corporation (SHE:000063) to pay a licensing fee to use the Android OS for their range of smartphones. While Microsoft is on rampage to sign more number of Android vendors to make sure its Android-cash-bank gets richer, M-Cam, a global financial institution has studied several of these patents and has revealed in a report that Microsoft’s claim on these patents is not as robust as previously imagined.

These revelations come to light after the full list of 310 patents was submitted to the Chinese government as part of the review of the purchase of the Nokia acquisition. This follows soon after it was concluded Microsoft’s licensing power could be used to pursue Chinese smartphone vendors, most of whom use Google Android as the primary OS for their range of smartphones. android_microsoft_money

Microsoft Is Earning Billions Every Quarter Through Android

Throughout 2013, Microsoft reportedly earned a whopping US$3.4 Billion through sales of Android smartphones alone. Since 2010, Microsoft has reportedly rounded up 70% of all Android device manufacturers to pay royalty for the use of its patents. During  the same period, in Q2 2013 last year, the software giant earned a total of US$1.51 Billion from Android smartphone vendors. HTC reportedly pays a total of US$5 per Android phone sold to Microsoft,while the largest Android vendor Samsung paid as much as US$12 per Android device sold. This figure is estimated to have far exceeded the revenue generated from the sales of Windows phone devices and also allows Microsoft to recover any losses from the X-box, Skype or Surface division. It’s important to note these earnings to Microsoft came from the sales of Android smartphones alone, while the company also enjoys similar royalty arrangements on Android tablet devices. Therefore, it’s easy to understand that Microsoft’s last year’s earnings from Android, in total, would be at least 15% – 20% higher than US$3. 4 billion.7624.androidpatent

The question remains as to whether Microsoft actually owns proprietary rights to the Android OS or is it unfairly exploiting device makers through an uninformed belief in its supposed innovation. Nearly 70% of Android OEMs have willingly agreed to pay the licensing fee, as they remain wary of the costs of a long drawn-out court battle. Motorola mobility, however, has won several of these cases and has forced some major firms to reconsider their licensing agreements with Microsoft. 

Only 21% of Patents Held Had Any Commercial Relevance

Now revelations have also emerged from China, where Microsoft is facing difficulty as the country remains wary of the US technology, as recently demonstrated by the ban on Windows 8 on government computers. To maintain their profits, it is likely that Chinese Android smartphone vendors will resist paying any licensing fee to Microsoft. By making the patent list public, Microsoft may have unwittingly allowed other smartphone vendors to discover whether they have similar patents which precede Microsoft’s patents. This may allow them to negotiate with the tech giant for a better deal.  Patents

Interestingly, it was revealed that only 21% of Microsoft’s patents was classified as commercial while 79% was classified as non-commercial. This implies that only a fifth of these patents was relevant, as non-commercial patents have little chance of being licensed and lack market relevance. Also, there are at least 11,000 expired patents from the Android innovation space and another 14,000 from the abandoned Android innovation space. It is believed that companies can now find free alternatives to the Microsoft licensing package.companies which have patents

Moving on to the 127 patent agreement Microsoft holds, even more surprising results were unearthed. At least 40 of Microsoft’s Android patents were proceeded by patents from other companies, which were not mentioned by Microsoft. This finding casts a shadow of doubt over the remaining patents as well. Companies such as Dell Inc. (NASDAQ:DELL), Sony Corp (ADR) (NYSE:SNE) and Panasonic Corporation (ADR) (OTCMKTS:PCRFY) had previously signed licensing agreements with Microsoft.

Microsoft May Not Be Able To Milk Android For Much Longer

The above findings illustrate that Microsoft’s claim on the Android smartphone is not as strong as previously suggested. It also reveals how dependant Microsoft is on Android. As the sales of Windows phones devices and Surface tablets struggling to grow, Microsoft depends largely on the licensing fees to appease worried investors. Royalty payments notwithstanding, the Redmond Giant is also using a forked Android to power the Nokia X range of devices.

According to previous estimations Microsoft’s licensing fee revenues could soar to as much as US$8.8 billion by 2017. That now seems unlikely as the next few years will see several legal and business challenges to Microsoft’s Android patent portfolio. There are enough evidences suggesting that several companies, including the largest payer Samsung, are all set to oppose Microsoft’s licensing deals both legally and commercially.


  1. Hahahahaha. This is what happens when you have no ethics. Welcome to Karma Microsoft. The best part is they can be sued into oblivion now for this. They don’t get to keep the money they knowingly stole from people. And China is the worst place to test this. This could very well be the end of Microsoft. Not kidding.

  2. JamesNorrington I’m not so sure…  it would be in their best long-term interests to combine forces against Microsoft to obviate any need to pay “royalties”.  It’s appearing more and more like Microsoft never did any innovation in the Android space to begin with, and merely bought existing patents that were on shaky ground, anyway.  Why wouldn’t a consortium of Android device manufacturers not want to free themselves from a swindle like this one?

  3. oh, you wish! haha are you paid by google or something? anway, android manufactures will keep paying patent fees. don’t worry. 🙂


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -

Latest News

Is the reason convincing enough to ditch iPhone 14 Pro Max?

It's not even a month since Apple launched iPhone 14 series, and the internet is abuzz with rumours, speculations...
- Advertisement -

In-Depth: Dprime

Will ‘TikTok By Microsoft’ Be A Winner?

For the last two years, TikTok has been in the public eye for all sorts of reasons. First, it was the exploded and unparalleled...

More Articles Like This